Candy Scar: 12 Moments Fans Keep Going Back To

Candy Scar is not a video most people watch once. It runs 4:11, it is scored like a sugar advert, and it carries an entire tragedy in flashback underneath the choreography — so the second and third watches find things the first one skated over.

This is the list of what the fandom keeps going back to.

How to read this

An earlier version of this page gave a timestamp for every entry. Those timestamps were invented and have been removed, along with several “moments” that never happened. What is here now is the documented sequence of the video, in order, with a clear line between the two kinds of claim:

• On screen — described in the episode and corroborated by the ALIEN STAGE Wiki’s transcription.
• The reading — what the fandom makes of it. Labelled every time.

If you want a time index, build it yourself against the official upload. We are not going to print one we have not verified.

1. The choir prologue

Before the beat exists, a choir sings four lines in English: “Those bound by iron chains now / They still stare toward the night / Wounded souls still breathing / Glory be upon them.”

Then the track cuts to “(Dreamy! Cutie! Love! Kyun!)” and never returns to that register.

The reading: the prologue is the only honest description of the performers in the whole song, and it is placed where a programme note goes — before the show, not inside it.

2. The two designs

The first full look at both performers is a shock beat by construction.

Mizi is in a pastel-pink strapless mini-dress, flared sparkling petticoat, high twin-tails with oversized bows — and where the upper half of her face should be there is a heart-shaped hole. Her eyes and nose are gone; they were taken by the owners of the stage. Infection runs down the right side of her jaw and throat, over her shoulder and across her upper back. There is a bite mark next to her mouth.

Sua is in white — puff sleeves, long gloves, a wide headscarf. A large dark gemstone covers the left side of her face and her left eye socket. Her right eye is a glassy purple. Her right leg is skeletal, exposed bone wrapped in rotting tissue; her left carries a black heart-shaped gem high on the thigh.

Both of them smile continuously.

The reading: the wound placement is not random. The idol lost her face; the girl who was never picked lost the leg. A lot of the fandom reads Sua’s skeletal leg as a comment on idol weight standards. That is interpretation, not text.

3. The audition they fail together

The flashback opens in high school. Mizi wants to be a K-pop idol and wants Sua in it with her. She shows Sua the application poster. They audition as a duo.

Both are rejected.

4. The audition only one of them passes

After graduation they practise and audition again. Mizi is clumsy at hers. The judges see more charm in her than in Sua, and take her.

Mizi is devastated that Sua was not accepted. At the start of her career the two of them are still close.

The reading: this is the fork the entire AU hangs on, and the episode gives it about fifteen seconds. Everything cruel that follows is downstream of one panel of judges.

5. The billboards

Mizi becomes famous on her looks. Her image goes up across the city, and she is pushed to sexualise herself for a male audience. The industry starts to reshape who she is.

6. The clematis handed to a staff member

Sua comes to see Mizi and brings her a bouquet of clematis flowers. Mizi smiles — and then, almost immediately, passes the bouquet to a nearby staff member and turns back to what looks like a photoshoot.

This is the single most-quoted beat of the video, and the one that hurts most in a series where My Clematis is the song Mizi and Sua sing to each other in the original universe.

The reading: Sua has stopped being a person to Mizi and become a fan with a gift. Whether that is contempt or self-protection is the fandom’s longest-running argument about this episode.

7. The cigarette and the slap

Sua catches Mizi smoking. Horrified at how far she has spiralled, she takes the cigarette out of Mizi’s hand and scolds her.

Mizi slaps her across the face.

The reading: Mizi has spent her career being managed and corrected, and reads Sua’s concern as one more person telling her what to do with her own body.

8. The hug, the panic, the mother

Sua, stunned, pulls Mizi into a hug anyway.

The contact triggers a severe panic attack, and a flashback to Mizi’s own mother — the only appearance Mizi’s mother makes in the episode. Mizi shoves Sua away and runs into the night.

9. The bite, seen from Sua’s side

During the escape, a zombie follows Mizi and bites her beside the mouth. That bite mark is the one visible on her face in the present-day performance.

The sequence is framed from Sua’s point of view. Sua is there. She sees the zombie following. She does not move.

The reading: the framing is the accusation, and the episode never states it out loud. Some of the fandom reads it as paralysis, some as choice. The next moment is the reason the second reading has traction.

10. The kiss

Later, Sua slips past a guard and gets into the building where the infected Mizi is being held. She is crying and blushing at once. She opens Mizi’s mouth with her fingers and kisses her — infecting herself deliberately, so that the outbreak cannot separate them.

This is the beat that reframes the entire song. When the lyrics say 너는 나의 신이야 / 너는 나의 우주야 (“you are my god / you are my universe”) in what is otherwise stock fan-chant vocabulary, Sua is being literal.

11. The line about rotting

Late in the song, in the same bright register as the pudding-and-jelly hook: 함께 썩어가는거야 미쳐 아름답게 — “we’ll rot away together, beautifully insane.” The line after it is 여긴 이미 낙원인 걸, “this place is already paradise.”

Nothing in the delivery changes. That is the point of the song, delivered without a single dramatic cue.

12. The hand-hold, and the table

At the end of the performance Sua takes Mizi’s hand and holds it tightly. Mizi barely responds.

Then the result: Mizi wins by one point. Sua is laid on a slaughtering table. Her arm is cut off and sold to the audience. She does not struggle. An acapella pass of Little Bunny — a nursery rhyme about a rabbit hopping into the forest with dirt on its paws — plays over it.

The song’s own outro has already told you how this goes. It counts down (셋, 둘.) — “three, two” — and never reaches one. What follows instead is (마지막.), “last one.” The count is finished by the result, not by the music.

How to rewatch on purpose

• Watch it twice back to back. The first pass is the performance; the second is the flashback, which is cut so tightly against the choreography that it is easy to lose on a first viewing.
• Keep the full lyric page open. Korean, romanization and English side by side, so you can see how the cheerful line and the grim line are the same line.
• Then read the line-by-line meaning essay. It goes through the concessive clauses — “even if we break,” “even if we’re erased” — that the arena makes literal.
• Screenshot from the official upload. Fair use covers fan commentary. Do not repost paywalled Patreon pages.
• Or play it: the rhythm mini-game at /candy-scar-game/ runs on the song’s own structure.

---

Have a moment we missed, or a correction with a source behind it? Email [email protected]. Sourced additions get added and the page gets re-dated.